Sunday, August 22, 2010

theconflict2010

3 comments:

  1. Comments by other people

    This is a thought provoking film that attempts to unravel the many layers of the Kandhamal Story and make some connections between the communal as well as corporate-backed violence that has convulsed Odisha today…. Arundhati Roy, writer.

    "The Conflict vividly captures the plight of the adivasis of Odisha which Kandhamal and Kashipur exemplify, The film brings to us in the words of the adivasis themselves how their loss of access to land and forest resources has created a crisis in society and polity which are manipulated by political parties, mining companies and communal organisations, especially the Hindutva forces causing a cycle of violence.”… Prof. Manoranjan Mohanty, President, Odisha Gabeshana Chakra
    Retired Professor, Delhi University.

    “Located in the troubled adivasi areas of southern Orissa, this film patiently shows us the complex ways in which the communal division of adivasi people is being used to prepare the grounds for Hindutva, a process which deepens existing divisions, and allows the government and the mining corporates to begin the process of the dispossession of people from their lands.”…Sanjay Kak, film maker.

    “An important film to understand complexities of Kandhmal violence in Orissa. An integral part of Cinema of Resistance Film Festivals initiative in Northern India.”
    Sanjay Joshi, Convener, Gorakhpur Film Festival and THE GROUP (film group of Jan Sanskriti Manch).

    ReplyDelete
  2. From magazine and newspaper


    THE HINDU
    Friday Review Bangalore Friday, Dec 11, 2009
    Who's land is it?

    “W e are not citizens anymore, we have become stakeholders. The idea of citizenship is gone.” This troubling assessment of our nation's relationship with its people was made by Debranjan Sarangi, the maker of ‘The Conflict: Whose Loss, Whose Gain?' (2009, 80 minutes).
    Sarangi, who has been an activist in his native Orissa for almost two decades now, made this statement while explaining how tribal communities were being displaced in large parts of Orissa as the state endorsed the move by large corporations to exploit the vast natural wealth that lay beneath their lands.
    “The state is taking resources from the small stakeholders and giving it to the big stakeholders. There is no political or economic space for the small stakeholders now.” Sarangi was trying to explain how the Indian state has ignored the rights of tribal communities. This theme of adivasi displacement in parts of Orissa, forms one of the two major themes that Sarangi has chosen to depict in his first documentary film. The other theme that the film dwells upon is the communal relations in Kandhamal after the anti-Christian violence that took place in that district last year.
    The film was publicly screened last Friday by the media-activist organisation Pedestrian Pictures (they have also produced the film) in Bangalore. Displaying a fine understanding of its subject matter, the film tries to give voice to the poor adivasis and Dalits of the districts of Rayagada and Kandhamal in Orissa. The documentary looks at the struggles of the adivasis in Kashipur in Rayagada against the large companies that made them shift out of their ancestral lands by falsely promising jobs and compensation and using the power of the state to effect this displacement. One of the adivasis in the film sums up the sentiment well when he says: “Our fight is for our land, our forest, our water, our river, our air. It is our land — we have been living here for ages”.
    On the other hand, the film also shows how the Christian community in Kandhamal has become vulnerable to an aggressive Hindutva that tends to categorise them as converts.
    ‘Globalisation' and ‘Communalism' are two very different problems, are they not? Sarangi has an answer to the question even though he acknowledges that a solid tangible connection is hard to formulate – “When you hate someone, you lose your humanity. This is clear when you target people of other religions but in the name of development, large corporations with the support of the state are also targeting tribal communities losing their humanity.”
    Sarangi's politics is highly communitarian – “I am anti-corporation, anti-state. Society should be community based. The individual is not supreme and there should be no individualism within the community. The state should respect the community and not do things against the community.” While this seems classically a Marxist position, Sarangi is careful to clarify that while Marx's work helped him understand ideas of ‘conflict' he does not believe in the ‘revolution of the proletariat' describing his politics as ‘broadly Marxist' but strongly independent. This is also reflected in the way in which he went about making his film – by soliciting funds from individuals rather than sponsoring agencies because he wanted complete autonomy with his ideas. It took a year to make the film and he plans to screen the film widely in his native Orissa.
    By VIKHAR AHMED SAYEED

    ReplyDelete
  3. Of lands and cultures - The Conflict
    By Savitha Babu, 15 Mar 2010
    http://thealternative.in/articles/of-lands-and-cultures---the-conflict
    A documentary capturing the filmmaker's journey to the Kashipur and Kandhamal districts of Orissa, in the aftermath of the communal riots
    A people who have lost their land and identity. Pic Courtesy: Ped Pics
    It is the story of a people who have lost their land and identity, and strive to find new meanings. “The Conflict” is a documentary that records director Debaranjan Saarangi’s journey to Kashipur and Kandhamal districts of Orissa. The journey was undertaken with three tribal leaders in August 2008, in the aftermath of the Kandhamal riots.
    Two strands run parallel in the film- in Kashipur, the conflict is between the Kondh tribe and a multinational supported by a “corporatised State”. In Kandhamal, the focus is on the impact the riots have had on the tribe.
    Culture and development are oft used words but what they mean remains obscure. Nobody disputes a well equipped hospital or school as being symbols of development. It is when not eating beef, bhajan mandals and other practices known to mainstream religions are defined as development that problems emerge. Acceptance of the cultural practices of another is fine but not when it comes at the cost of deriding what is one’s own. There are many intricacies to the issue, some of which are brought out powerfully in the film.
    The conflict is also amongst the young and the old who have opposing views on their own culture. Pic Courtesy: Ped Pics
    The erosion of cultural identities is established by contrasting the views of the young and the old. The head priest in Kashipur, an old woman describes the 12 festivals of the Kondh tribe for the 12 seasons. She talks of worshipping nature and animals sacrificed on special occasions to please the Gods. These include chickens, pigs and cows. A contrast is established through tribal leader Krishna Mahji’s conversation with a group of youngsters near Kandhamal that comes immediately after. A youngster argues vehemently against beef eating. He is unwilling to hear opinions contrary to his own, and walks away with an expression of disgust when attempts are made to debate the issue further.
    The issue here is not about eating beef. It is the assertion of supremacy of a certain way of life, the same assertion that had been used to justify the caste system. Acceptance of the Hindu or brahminical view as superior seems to be alienating many youngsters from their religion.

    ReplyDelete